October 23, 2015

Please reload

Recent Posts

Making accounting more accessible through the SAICA-accreditation of the Institute of Accounting Science as a new private institution

August 24, 2017

Please reload

Featured Posts

Does it pay to be bad?

October 23, 2015


Much attention has been paid to sustainability, being environmentally conscious, and being a good corporate citizen. Many investment studies have examined whether being a good corporate citizen pays, or more specifically, whether it pays to be a more responsible investor, investing only in companies that are ‘good’ companies.


Surely, it should pay to be good, and cost to be bad?


A recent article by Credit Suisse deviated from focussing on ‘good’ companies, and instead investigated whether it would be profitable to invest in ‘bad’ companies, or companies that were in less environmentally friendly industries. This was examined through the monitoring of a UK vice fund, which was compared to a market tracking index, and it was found that the vice fund outperformed the FTSE social index fund over a period of 12 years.




This leads one to question whether in a South African context, the same holds? To test this from a shorter term perspective, we used the tobacco industry (J378) as a proxy for ‘bad’ companies, and compared this to the return achieved on the top 40 shares, measured using the SATRIX 40 index (STX40). The results indicate that in almost all of the periods tested, the tobacco industry has outperformed the market significantly. In particular, over the last three years, while the Satrix 40 increased by 52%, a pleasant enough return, the tobacco industry increased by a whopping 75%.




In conclusion therefore… Perhaps investing in ‘bad’ does warrant some further investigation…


Published in Standard Bank Newsletter 2015



Please reload

Follow Us
Please reload

Search By Tags
Please reload

  • Facebook Basic Square
  • Twitter Basic Square
  • Google+ Basic Square


+27 (0)82 415 9011
+27 (0)11 867 1013


DCA Campus

30 Doncaster Road

New Market Park




Interested in joining us?

Click below to express interest and obtain more information regarding our program - no obligation, no fee...

Jan 2021 applications are now open!


  • w-facebook
  • Twitter Clean


    © 2020 Institute of Accounting Science (Pty) Ltd